Supervisions in Pain

Episode 5: "What is my scope?"

Where does your role end and another clinician’s begin? That’s the core question on the table in this episode of Supervisions in Pain, as Alex and James welcome IRS Occupational Therapist Chloe May for a deep dive into clinical scope in community care. While boundaries seem simple on paper, real-world community work often blurs the lines across multidisciplinary teams.

Together, they bring two complex client stories to the supervision table to dissect where things went well and where there was room for improvement. Chloe highlights key takeaways on handling moral dilemmas, reaching out for clinical guidance, and navigating handover pathways when client needs evolve. Tune in to gain practical strategies that will help you evaluate your own scope boundaries with greater confidence and clarity.

Resources:

Click below to view transcript

James: Hello, welcome back to Supervisions in Pain. As a refresher, my name’s James, this is Alex. We’re both neurological physiotherapists who work in the community space in Melbourne and have a special interest in chronic pain. In this episode, we’re bringing in another special guest to help us explore the challenges of scope of practice in the chronic pain space. Firstly, looking at what we can and cannot treat, and then delving into that uncomfortable grey space of roles that can blend between physio, occupational therapy, psychology, social work, and case management. As always, we’ll bring a couple of clients to the supervision session to figure out what’s working well and what we could do better. Then we’ll come back at the end to discuss some resources to help us reinforce our scopes, and then some strategies to help set boundaries. Finally, we’ll leave you with three take-homes that may help you in your own practice.
Alex: Welcome to Supervisions in Pain. We are cracking on with our fifth episode, which is around scope, scope of practice. What is our job? What is our scope as community clinicians working with pain clients, particularly in this world of complexity and grey? Scope is a big topic, and oftentimes the definitions can be blurry. Before we crack on, we have a very special guest, our beloved colleague, Chloe May. Chloe is an OT who works at our practice at IRS. Chlo, do you want to introduce yourself and what you do?
Chloe: I’m excited to be on the podcast. I work as a community OT, and I’ve only worked in the community rehab space in my professional career. I really view my role as an OT in this persistent pain world as supporting clients return to valued and meaningful activities in a really graded manner and approach. I’ve certainly had some experience working in bigger multidisciplinary teams, but then also working quite individually one-to-one with clients who present with persistent pain who might not be linked in. I guess this conversation around scope of practice is quite topical given OTs can wear many hats at times, keen to get stuck into it.
Alex: The many hats of OTs. You guys have a massive job, and I think even amongst other healthcare providers your scope is confusing and massive. It’d be really great to sort of pick your brain on where you can perceive your role to begin and end. James, you’ve also, along with Chloe, brought a case study to chat about. Before we get stuck into those, we can have a chat about what scope of practice means to the both of you. I’ll just go through what it means at an AHPRA level. They’re our main professional body for OT and physio, and they define scope of practice as “the professional role and services that an individual health practitioner is trained, qualified, and competent to perform.” AHPRA splits this definition into two layers: the professional layer is what the entire profession is legally permitted to do, and individual layer, which is what you personally have the education and skills to do safely. Just curious, how much pain formal education did you receive at a university level before entering into this space?
James: That’s a good question. Pretty minimal. I think it was one lecture. Full stop. It wasn’t hugely well-researched at the time, and it takes another 5 to 10 years for that to bleed out into the courses and the content there. I felt really ill-equipped in this space coming into the professional world, which is why I think I dedicated so much time and attention to it. If we were looking at that definition, my first few weeks of practice, my professional scope would have been pretty narrow.
Alex: How about you, Chlo?
Chloe: Very similar to James. I think maybe one single lecture as well, and some minor discussions here and there just one-to-one with lecturers. Same with my experience coming into more practical roles, and when I first started at IRS, it was more through mentoring and supervision that I really got fed more information and research and shown the different tools to use, because it’s such a different approach that we do need to take. I had a big learning experience straight out the gates with one of my first clients being a persistent pain client. I went in guns blazing with, “I knew what I was going to do,” and I had this plan. After speaking to my supervisor, she was like, “Maybe let’s just take a step back and try these other strategies.” Similar to James, I then invested a bit of my first year just having a look at what’s out there and the different ways of approaching this type of intervention.
Alex: It’s really wild that oftentimes the primary reason—I’ll speak for physios, but the primary reason that clients, particularly off the street, come in to see physio is because they’re in discomfort. The fact that I graduated 17 years ago, but there was one lecture on persistent pain, and persistent pain clients were essentially made out to be these very psychologically entangled, socially dysfunctional, problem clients where you had to use a completely different model of care, and it was very confusing and really poorly taught. We’re all coming out of uni ill-equipped to work with this population group, which is really sad. I think it’s getting better, I hope. The other thing about scope is that it’s dynamic. With every course or mentoring or supervision we do, our scope broadens and we become more specialised, better equipped to manage certain clinical situations. In pain, there’s also some tricky spots we can find ourselves in where, as private practitioners, we work with paying customers who are expecting a service, and pain in the general population isn’t as well-understood as it could be, so there’s a lot of misinformation out there among our patients and clients about what they want from our services. I find that to be a tricky space. James and Chlo, I’m sure you both have examples where a client has said, “I want this mattress, and the mattress is going to fix my back pain,” or “I want this massage and that’s going to fix my hip,” or whatever.
James: Absolutely. Have a go at it.
Alex: Should we talk about some case studies?
James: Let’s do it.
Chloe: Let’s do it.
Alex: James, you want to kick us off?
James: Sure. The person that came to mind for me—I’ll introduce him first. He was a 60-year-old guy, moderate traumatic brain injury, multi-orthopaedic injuries from a high-speed motorbike accident. He had chronic shoulder, back, knee pain, and would get these really severe flare-ups. He was super boom-busty. He’d try and do everything and then fall into a heap with a lot of catastrophisation, and a very complex social history. Went through the foster system as a child, had a criminal history including some gang affiliation, previous drug and alcohol use and dependency, periods of homelessness. When I started to see him, he was at the time experiencing pretty severe periods of depression and paranoia as well. All of those life experiences for him accumulated into this lack of trust of anyone, particularly new people, which is where I came across the challenge of blurred lines of scope of practice pretty early on in my career. My early role really was to gain his trust, ensure he had adequate supports around, a well-built multidisciplinary team, and then get him moving at home so he could function without care supports because there was a long history of conflict and relationship breakdown between carers and himself over time, that wasn’t sustainable. He’d refused any social work or psych at the time. What I found over time was that every session that I would go there, there’d be a new barrier because his life was pretty chaotic. There’d be a new financial issue, there’d be an issue with the neighbour that was causing a lot of angst and conflict for him, which was having an impact on his pain experience. He sometimes drove without his licence, so there’d be a police issue. I found my role over time starting to become less and less about the physio input that I’d planned, and more about just putting out spot fires, trying to remove barriers that kept on getting in the way, as well as becoming what felt like more of a social worker in a sense that our sessions at the start would often have a 5 to 10 minute debrief and chat, reflection on the previous session, bit of a subjective assessment. Over time, that became more and more just an opportunity for him to talk to someone because he didn’t have many other people in his life that he trusted, vent, talk about issues in his life at the time, and that would become longer and longer through the sessions. To the point where I started getting this feeling of, “I don’t know if I’m actually being an effective physio at the moment, or I don’t know if I’m even being a physio for him, full stop.” It was less of a concern about my scope of practice in the sense that I didn’t feel like I was providing a service that was outside the black-and-white scope of physio practice, but I was not doing the job that I was an expert in, that someone else could be doing a better job of instead. I just felt stuck. It’s a pretty uncomfortable feeling.
Alex: You were an early-career clinician at this point, were you?
James: This was in my first year.
Alex: Even then, you still have that feeling?
James: It was a combination of a lot of different feelings. There was frustration, sometimes at the situation, sometimes a direct frustration at him that I really just want to get stuck into the pain stuff, but couldn’t. I didn’t have that distance to see that I was enabling that by being a supportive ear for him to talk to. There was a frustration at myself, a frustration at him sometimes, a feeling of just being stuck, we weren’t making the progress that I was hoping to, which I think just comes naturally with working in the chronic pain space early in the career anyway, because it doesn’t progress the way other musculoskeletal injuries might progress. There was a lot in there that I was trying to unpack. Supervision at that time was really helpful because it gave me that opportunity to step back and see it a little bit more objectively, have someone call out some patterns and some things that we were wading into murky waters with the psych stuff, social worker stuff, and to help me come up with a bit of a better treatment plan for that, set some expectations.
Alex: It makes me reflect on how it’s almost twofold. It’s understanding your scope, and then it’s also the very active work of setting boundaries around the scope. If you don’t know what that is in the moment or as an early-career clinician, that is incredibly difficult to do. What ended up happening with this person? What were things that you could have done differently, what went well?
James: If I had come across this client now, there would have been a few things done differently. It was very important at the start to establish that trust and take a little bit of extra time doing that because of his history, but a lot earlier on in the piece I would have set some clear expectations around, “This is what I can support you with, but more importantly, this is what I cannot.” “For us to continue to make progress towards the things that are really important to you, we will need to bring in whether it was going to be a psych for him at the time or a social worker for him to have that opportunity to work through that stuff with them, so that I could actually be effective at my job and help him with the physio-related stuff.” I would have been a bit clearer with him earlier on, for sure.
Alex: Would he have been open to that?
James: I was a little bit too precious with the therapeutic relationship, because I was going through my own early-career imposter syndrome and all that kind of thing. I wanted to keep the relationship there. I didn’t want to ruffle any feathers. Whereas now, I’m confident that just having an open conversation about that early, after having established some trust and getting a couple of wins on the board, could be a really easy conversation to have. Maybe not easy, but comfortable.
Chloe: You’re also just trying to keep momentum during these phases as well, where you’re thinking, “Yes, this person could really support this client,” whether it’s case management, psychology, social work, but there’s waitlists that are out there. A lot of the time you end up wearing that hat for longer than you’re anticipating because you feel it’s easier.
James: Totally. It’s not you’re just, all of a sudden, making a conscious decision to be like, “I’m going to chuck on a social worker’s hat today.” It’s this slow thing over time, if we see a client for 6, 12 months, that happens insidiously. It starts off with just this relationship building, client-centred approach that then shifts into a 5-minute conversation, and then it’s a 6-minute conversation, and then all of a sudden half your session’s taken up with this thing. It happens over time.
Chloe: It comes back to expectation setting too, because then it’s really hard to come back from that once you’ve let that slip for so long, and they’re like, “I can come to you, and you have been supporting me with these other goals as well.” It highlights that re-establishment of boundaries regardless where you are in that journey.
James: That would have been the thing that had a much higher risk of damaging the therapeutic relationship, 6 months down the track, then taking the step back and saying, “I can’t do that.”
Alex: If you do find yourself in a tricky spot where you are in that position where an empathic boundary has not been established, and you are uncomfortable wearing this hat, the more experience you get, you feel more confident in the little ruptures and repairs that you can have with your clients, trusting that they are human adults who can also have challenging conversations and recover from them. Super tough. What happened when you started to steer the ship back in the right direction, what was that process for you?
James: The harder part was the planning and preparation for that conversation in my mind. He was an adult human, he handled it fine. It was really just about re-establishing the importance of bringing in a social worker or a psych—we ended up settling on a social worker—to come and be that trusted outlet that he could talk with throughout the week. The social worker would report to me so that I wouldn’t be bringing up that stuff separately in my sessions. It was expected that they would come to me with any flags or concerns that would impact his treatment. I just went pretty straight down the line, chronic pain physio hat.
Alex: Was that effective?
James: As effective as it could have been for someone in his position. He was quite a complex guy to work with, but that uncomfortable feeling in the gut disappeared, and I could actually focus on clinical outcomes and what we needed to work on. The conversation then became at the start of the session, “How’s your week been?” and then that was it. He understood that if there was anything that needed to be talked about, the social worker would have come to me about it, and we would have explored it further.
Alex: That’s such a good share. Everyone would have a story that.
James: Absolutely. For me, thinking back, the importance of the supervisor in that relationship can’t be undersold. Not having an objective set of eyes on my treatment plan with him, it’s really hard to pick up on that stuff yourself, to have that insight and reflective practice early on in your careers as a new physio, as a new clinician working in the pain space, where those lines do blur a lot between OT and psych and physio. It’s essential to have a mentor, a supervisor to talk through those clients with, to make sure you’re staying on track.
Alex: Completely. Especially when you’ve done 1 hour of lecture at uni on how to manage this situation. Chlo, you’re nodding along, I’m guessing you have a very similar experience you want to share with us?

Chloe: I can completely sit in the same situation as you, James, and I can think of many examples of where it takes that objective outlook in to go, “This is where things are leading, and you’re progressively taking this client over time, and you need that supervisor or mentor to help you also see that bigger picture when you’re just seeing them week to week.” I definitely have a case example where I was an early-career clinician and was originally referred to this client with quite a specific goal in mind. This gentleman experienced a severe motor vehicle accident with multitrauma injuries, was experiencing some psychiatric concerns as well post-accident, and having a really challenging time readjusting. He had a young family that he was financially supporting, and his wife was just coming off the back of maternity leave and studying, so he had a lot of that external pressure on him to take care of his family. This referral was mainly driven by a pain specialist, and my client was, interestingly, part of a clinic-based pain program for 20 weeks. He was super engaged, showing up to every single appointment, but just not making much progress because he had pretty poor sleep hygiene and was not able to get the rest and recoup in between each of his clinic appointments. The clinic team asked for a community OT, being me, to come in and try to help him at home establish some more steady routines to help him and achieve better sleep overnight. They had some ideas around scripting specific bits of equipment that would hopefully alleviate some of these limitations that he was experiencing at home. I had a very clear-cut role going in in terms of what the wider team were expecting of me being as the community OT. When I met the client, what I saw in person was a gentleman that was really unwell with his mental health, really struggling to look after his family, experiencing a lot of loss of identity, helplessness, hopelessness. He was very impacted physically with his persistent pain, very limited mobility, extreme muscle guarding, fear avoidance, didn’t really move around the house too much, and just stayed seated most of the day. When I walked in, it just wasn’t what I was expecting. Often when we have the referral come in, and then from what I was seeing, I straight away was feeling something was a little bit off, and that the original goal that was proposed and brought to me, I felt a mattress wasn’t going to cut it, and wasn’t going to fix any of the difficulties that he was having. I was in quite a conflicted position because I was like, “Okay, the team expects this of me, and the client also expects this of me because that’s what’s been sold to him, and he has this understanding that by me coming in and giving this piece of equipment, it’s going to significantly improve his quality of life and function”. But looking at that, I felt like I really needed to take a step back. Again, similarly to James, I went to supervision and kind of said, “This is what the referral asked for, but this is what I saw and what I’m feeling, and I’m really uncomfortable with this, but I don’t know what to do because I don’t want to step on anyone’s toes, and I don’t want to let the team down, and I don’t want to let the client down”.

Through supervision, we navigated having that conversation with the referrer first, because they were the lead of the team. I was able to explain the clinical reasoning behind why jumping straight to equipment without addressing these foundational barriers—the mental health, the lack of support, the extreme fear avoidance—was actually likely going to do more harm than good and set him up for failure. To their credit, they were really receptive to that feedback once it was framed around the client’s holistic presentation and safety.
From there, we had to re-align expectations with the client. That was really nerve-wracking, but we broke it down into smaller, meaningful steps rather than a quick-fix piece of equipment. We worked on very graded pacing, small routines around the house, and getting other appropriate supports linked in, rather than just ticking a box for a mattress prescription. It really taught me that even when you’re given a very specific referral request, your scope as an individual clinician means using your own assessment and not just blindly doing what you’re told if it doesn’t align with best practice or what the client genuinely needs.
Alex: That’s such a valuable example, because that pressure often comes from other clinicians or referrers who might have a very narrow idea of what our role is, or who are looking for a quick solution.
When we look at navigating these challenges, having concrete frameworks and resources to fall back on makes setting those boundaries much easier. Let’s touch on some of the key resources and practical strategies that clinicians can use to reinforce their scope.
First and foremost is your professional board guidelines—so whether that is AHPRA, the Physiotherapy Board of Australia, or Occupational Therapy Board of Australia. Familiarising yourself with the specific codes of conduct and scope statements gives you the objective backing to say, “This sits outside my competencies or regulatory scope”.
Beyond formal guidelines, what other tools or strategies have both of you found useful when you need to maintain or reset those boundaries?
James: For me, a big one is having standardised phrasing ready to go for setting expectations in initial sessions. Rather than leaving it open-ended, framing what physio can and cannot provide from day one removes the awkwardness later. Saying something along the lines of: “My role here is to focus on your physical function, movement, and pain education. Because pain impacts so many areas of life, if other challenges like mental health, housing, or social stresses come up, my job is to help you connect with the right professionals for those areas so that we can keep our time focused on your physical goals.”
Setting that contract early normalises referrals to psychology or social work before a crisis occurs.
Chloe: Absolutely. From an OT perspective, using objective goal-setting tools like the COPM (Canadian Occupational Performance Measure) or Goal Attainment Scaling really anchors the sessions. When conversations start drifting into that grey space of venting or unrelated problem-solving, you can bring it back to the agreed goals and ask, “How does what we’re talking about today relate to the goals we set to get you back to your gardening or walking to the shops?” It gently refocuses the session without invalidating their feelings.
And regular peer supervision or mentoring cannot be overstated. Having a scheduled space to debrief complex caseloads keeps you accountable before those boundaries slowly slip.
Alex: To wrap up today’s session, let’s leave everyone with our three key take-homes from this discussion:
  1. Scope is dynamic, but individual: Just because a profession broadly covers an area doesn’t mean you personally have the training or capacity to manage it safely; practice within your current competency and use professional development and supervision to expand it intentionally.
  2. Set expectations early and contract clearly: Establish the parameters of your role in the initial assessment so that introducing multidisciplinary team members later feels like a planned progression rather than a rejection.
  3. Use ruptures as opportunities to reset: If you find yourself wearing too many hats or sliding into an uncomfortable grey space, it’s never too late to pause, seek supervision, and have an honest conversation to re-establish healthy therapeutic boundaries.
Thank you both so much for sharing your experiences, and thank you, Chloe, for joining us!
Chloe: Thanks for having me.
James: Thanks everyone, see you next episode.

Connect with us

Have a complex case or a specific challenge you’re facing in the community? Get in touch via your direct line to Alex and James – learning@independent-rehab.com.au